Diri wrote:I disagree, kake...
Because it is in man's nature to name things differently by their quality - to distinquish them from other similar things/names...
When speaking we say "Badimcan" for tomatoes, and "Badimcana Reş" for aubergine...
One can only distinguish the two by color or shape if both are named "Badimcan"...
Hence the add-on "Reş" or "Sor"... So no - I disagree with you... What makes you think that Kurds borrowed that logic from the Turks? Who says it wasn't the other way around? We all know the Turks are descendants of a barbar central Asian culture - they had little or no knowledge of vegetables, agriculture etc...
So I stand firm - the add-on Reş or Sor is to distinguish the two from one another - because of their similarities in name - one is forced to point out the obvious characteristic difference (one being red and the other black) to create understanding...
Well I just explained you bro. Plants and vegetables such as tomatoes, potatoes, etc. come from the west therefore their names are western names (tomato, tomate, tomata, pomidor, etc.). But eggplants is native to the near east. In Iranian languages we have "badêmcan", "badimcan", "bayêncan", "bamcan", badêmcûn, "bacan", etc. to definite eggplants. No doubt that Turks are descendants of one the most ignorant races - barbars- ever seen. They had no knowledge of native near eastern vegetables and plants. Hence there are many Persian, Kurdish and Arabic words for vegetables and plants in different Turkic languages. Also its clear that Turkish might, like any other languages, have its own special elements/compositions. First Turks loaned "badimcan" from Kurdish or Persian then after introducing "tomatoes" they called this new plant "girmizi badimcan" and "bdimcan" as "qere badimcan". No doubt that this a Turkish composition, because main body of Azeri and central Turkish speakers say so and there is not such composition in any Kurdish dialects –except some Kurmancî varieties which are next to Turkish or Azeri populated areas- or other Iranian languages. Indeed Ottomans power and influence on the area by the time of introducing "tomatoes" could leave such effect.











